Father and Son Suffocate in Confined Space. Why?

All preventable workplace fatalities make me mad, but none make me madder than trench collapses and confined space fatalities. There is no reason for any of them to happen. The hazards of trenches and confined spaces are well known and there are good OSHA standards that would prevent these deaths if followed.

The first fatality I ever investigated at AFSCME was a confined space fatality in a Decatur, IL wastewater treatment plant. Wastewater treatment plants and sewer systems are notorious for confined space dangers because decaying sewage produces hydrogen sulfide, methane and oxygen shortages.  But that was 1983, before OSHA had a confined space standard and before Illinois had a public employee OSHA law.

But here we are 34 years later: 2 workers killed by gas at Miss. waste-water lift station.

Now I don’t know what happened here. Did one worker go down and pass out, and the other one go down to rescue him? It’s possible. Turns out the victims were father and son, 45-year-old Terry West and his 20-year-old son Gage West. This phenomenon is unfortunately not rare.  Until OSHA issued its general industry confined space standard in 1992, more rescuers died than original victims. And yet these cases continue to occur: One by one, 3 utility workers descended into a manhole. One by one, they died.

When a utility worker in Key Largo, Fla., noticed that a section of a paved street was not settling properly, he decided to remove a manhole cover and descend into the earth.

Moments later on Monday morning, the 15-foot-deep hole went silent. Sensing the man was trapped, a fellow utility worker climbed into the drainage hole to rescue him. When he, too, stopped responding, a third worker entered the same hole.

All three men died, overcome by poisonous fumes underground. They were identified as 34-year-old Elway Gray of Fort Lauderdale, 49-year-old Louis O’Keefe of Little Torch Key and 24-year-old Robert Wilson of Summerland Key.

OSHA’s general industry confined space standard was issued in 1992, but the agency didn’t get around to issuing a confined space standard for construction workers until 2015.  Confined spaces are work areas that (1) are large enough for an employee to enter, (2) have limited means of entry or exit, and (3) are not designed for continuous occupancy. They often have atmospheric or other hazards and can kill workers in minutes.

If a confined space is suspected to be hazardous, employers must designate it a “permit required confined space” and workers must be trained. The atmosphere must be tested and ventilated if found to be hazardous, and there must be special procedures for rescue.  The construction standard also has requirements that ensure that multiple employers share vital safety information and to continuously monitor hazards.

And it’s a good thing OSHA issued the construction standard in 2015. If it had been issued this year with Trump’s “one in/two out” Executive Order, OSHA might have had to remove protections for two other standards: maybe general industry workers in confined spaces don’t need protection any more. And we need to get rid of one more. Maybe the OSHA standard protecting workers from trench collapses?

OSHA’s Confined Space website can be found here.

Confined Space OSHA

1 Comment

  1. I’m very interested in this subject being an ex Marine engineer and currently a safety auditor and consultant. I’m sure yours aware that of the major causes of fatalities in confined spaces, is that of the sentry leaving the post and rushing into the space to attempt a rescue of a collapsed worker then consequently becoming a second victim of the same hazard. (Sometimes followed by a second and third would-be rescuer) To date the controls applied to this have been administrative in nature such as; training, permits to work, signage etc. However this issue continues to occur and result in approximately 1000 fatalities pa worldwide. We are developing an engineering solution to address this issue and I believe that it could be a game changer. A prototype production is currently underway.

    I would appreciate you opinion on whether my ideas are valid or not and I think the best thing (if you are agreeable) is to show you a powerpoint presentation on the product design using Skype. I would wish to record our skype conversation for confidentiality purposes and NDA agreement with you. I have received very positive feedback from practising safety managers here in NZ but it would be good to liaise with people like yourself involved with the wider industry.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.Required fields are marked *