One of the fathers of occupational health, Irving Selikoff, once said that “statistics are people with the tears wiped away.”
Today, the statistics look bad. This week we learned that coal mining deaths doubled in 2017, and rose to their highest point in three years. Fifteen miners died on the job in 2017, compared with eight in 2016, according to the Mine Safety and Health Administration (MSHA).
And a couple of weeks ago, we learned that in 2016, overall deaths in the workplace rose 7% over the year before, the third annual increase in a row. 5,190 fatal work injuries died on the job in 2016, 14 workers every day. We won’t know for almost a year how many non-coal mining workers died on the job in 2017.
Putting the Tears Back
But as Selikoff said, those are just numbers. This week, as I was compiling the Weekly Toll I ran across a few stories that should put some tears back in those numbers.
Buried Alive: Anyone who reads Confined Space on a regular basis knows that almost nothing makes me more angry than seeing workers buried alive in an unprotected trench. If you want to know more about the impact of such deaths, make sure you check out Jim Morris’s investigative piece last month, Death in a Trench.
Two workers died in trench collapses over the past couple of weeks. Zachary Hess died in a trench collapse in Warren County, Ohio, and Jesse Foster was killed in a trench collapse in Bell Aire, Kansas. Both are tragedies, but Hess’s death stands out. An estimated 150 people from rescue squads from around the area rushed to the scene in a vain attempt to rescue Hess. Despite firefighters clawing at the earth with their bare hands to get him out, the effort was hopeless. Hess was buried under tons of soil, 20 feet to 30 feet down. It took over 24 hours to recover the body.
What was especially infuriating about this death is that Hess’s employer, JK Excavating & Utilities of Mason, Ohio, was cited by OSHA just over three years ago for violations of OSHA’s trenching standard. The company received a $13,300 penalty, later reduced to $5,850. Somehow, the message that trenches over 5 feet deep have to be protected didn’t sink in as the company sent Zachary Hess to his death in a 20-30 foot, unprotected trench.
Machinery Rips Off Worker’s Leg: Domingo Alonzo Ramos was killed when his leg was ripped off after his foot got trapped in an auger used to grind meat scraps for garbage in a food processing plant in Canton, Ohio. “He screamed, and the other employees were able to stop the machine,” according to Rick Walters, investigator for the Stark County Coroner. They weren’t able to free him, however, and Ramos bled to death, Walters said. Ramos, a Guatemalan native, was undocumented and had worked at Fresh Mark, a meat processing facility, under an assumed name for over a year. In 2011, a worker at Fresh Mark’s Canton plant was electrocuted when he tried to plug in a fan while standing in water, according to OSHA, and the facility has received numerous OSHA citations over past several years for machine guarding and other violations.
And in case you think that deaths like this — cleaning up meat processing plants — are rare, check out Peter Waldman and Kartikay Mehrotra’s disturbing article last week “America’s Worst Graveyard Shift Is Grinding Up Workers.”
Boiled to Death: 28–year-old Frankie Crispin, Jr., a journeyman electrician at Columbia Forest Products in Klamath Falls, Oregon, was “found dead in a vat of scalding hot corrosive liquid. It appeared he fell through the lid of the vat, which sits a few feet above the ground.”
As the Oregonian described:
Frankie Crispen Jr. had a lot to look forward to this past November. He was set to take the rigorous exam that could elevate him to journeyman electrician after four years as an apprentice. Thanksgiving came the day after the state test, then it would be time to get serious about Christmas shopping.
On his final break the night of Nov. 17 at the Columbia Forest Products mill in Klamath Falls, Crispen texted his fiancée Ashley Albers, as he always did, teasing out the answers to his 11-year-old, soon-to-be stepdaughter’s math homework.
About an hour later, he responded to a call for an electrician over the intercom at the mill that sits on the banks of the Klamath River.
He was never seen alive again.
Are There Lessons To Be Learned?
I don’t have any good explanation about why fatalities are trending up — both in general industry and in coal mining. We could blame the increase in mining deaths on a message sent out to the industry that the Trump Administration will do anything (or overlook anything) to promote the mining industry. Of course that doesn’t explain the rise in 2016 deaths that occurred under the Obama administration.
All of these cases are in the early stages of investigation, but there are some lessons we can pull from these deaths.
Neither OSHA nor MSHA have received a budget increase since 2010 and, in fact, their budget have gone down in both real and inflation-adjusted terms. For OSHA, that has meant fewer enforcement staff every year, and fewer inspections. Add that to Trump’s hiring freeze, and as I wrote earlier, the agency’s enforcement and whistleblower programs are “falling apart at the seams,” according to OSHA staff.
All of the employers above had received previous OSHA citations, for Fresh Mark and JK Excavating, apparently for the exact hazards that killed their employees. Columbia Forest Products has also received past OSHA citations, although nothing major stands our for “America’s largest manufacturer of hardwood plywood and hardwood veneer products.”
I don’t know any more details of these deaths than I’ve read in the paper, but judging from the fact that Fresh Mark and JK Excavating were clearly aware of the hazards, I would hope they will receive willful citations –and with that the possibility of criminal prosecution.
We also know that none of the employers are union, which means that if the workers were worried about hazards in the workplace, they were likely afraid to bring them up to their employers or call OSHA (assuming they even knew what OSHA was.) And that goes doubly for Ramos who was undocumented and already under threat of deportation. Being represented by a union, is, of course, no guarantee that the employer will comply with the law, but it does raise the odds that workers will be knowledgeable about the hazards they face and able to exercise their rights with less fear of retaliation.
What Is To be Done? Turning Tears Into Action
So knowing what we know, what can we prescribe to make sure these deaths don’t happen again.
- Budget: Clearly OSHA and MSHA need significant budget increases. Enforcement and whistleblower programs need to be significantly increased so that there is a credible threat that an inspector will appear in any workplace at any time, and that employers who retaliate against workers will be sanctioned in a reasonable amount of time.
- Enforcement: OSHA, MSHA and Department of Labor leadership needs to send a strong message out — in word and in deed — that they will strongly enforce the law, including pursing criminal prosecutions. The Administration should also back legislation that would improve OSHA’s ability to pursue criminal prosecution and improve its weak whistleblower language.
- Compliance Assistance: OSHA’s compliance assistance dollars need to be focused on vulnerable workers who don’t have access to information about the hazards they face or their rights, and to small employers who may not have the resources to hire full-time health and safety staff and consultants.Undocumented workers need to understand that OSHA does not care about employment or immigration status when it comes to enforcing safe workplaces. This means increasing (and not eliminating) the Susan Harwood Training Grant Program that can provide training for workers that OSHA is otherwise unable to reach. Programs like the Voluntary Protection Programs (VPP) should continue to highlight those employers who exceed OSHA standards, but they should not be a drain on OSHA’s enforcement program.
- Unions: As I said above, workers in worksites with unions are more likely to be educated about their rights and the hazards they face, and are more likely to be able to use those rights to get employers to make their workplaces safer. Laws that make it easier for unions to organize and harder for anti-union employers to illegally oppose unions need to be strengthened.And unions themselves, although struggling, should be putting more resources, not fewer, into the health and safety of their members. Although it’s sometimes hard to understand at union headquarters, but members want and need the union’s assistance and support to ensure that they will come home in one piece at the end of the shift.
It’s the beginning of the year. Time to make plans and resolutions. Even in government agencies. So if anyone at OSHA or MSHA Is reading this, please forward a copy down to the Assistance Secretary’s office. I’m sure they’ll thank you for it.
6 thoughts on “Boiled to Death, Buried Alive and Leg Ripped Off: The Stories Behind the Statistics”
Thanks, Jordan for your vigilance. I think I’ve mentioned I started in OSH back in 1979 with the OSH Rev Comm, and worked at USDOL for many years including on OSH enforcement and regulation. I’m still at it albeit with another employer, and very little seems to have changed. Workplace fatalities is not the only area where progress is unraveling; look at the toll on young workers (especially taking into account the extent to which young workers are under represented in official injury and esp illness statistics.
My comment: these are compelling arguments that we must do more. But is there anyone listening who can/will make a difference? We seem to have gone beyond the point where facts and logic still have impact, except perhaps at the margins. The OSH system we have in the US depends greatly on the trust it has placed in national and state leadership; in many places and cases, that leadership has not lived up to its responsibility. I suppose the same could be said for healthcare, financial regulation, infrastructure development, education, the environment, and perhaps even the rule of law. Seems to me we have a lot of brush fires out there demanding our attention, and not a lot of response capacity. Okay, thanks, rant over. Keep up the great work!
This is a continuing story – no one in POWER cares. Workers are cheap and the state protects the company. In INDIANA employees or their dependents cannot sue the company.
I am speaking on my behalf of my son Zach Hess to increase awareness on trench safety. His death was 100% preventable
Hello Cindy. Could you please reach out to me
Accidents will still happen… Nothing can or will make it 100%.. it’s a shame anyone gets hurt but please think twice about more laws and government… Working in the field for 20 yrs is why I say this,,, book smarts only go so far. Work in the field before saying what we need. Education would be a big plus but book smart inspectors or permits don’t make it safer… We try our best and hindsight is always 20/20. Thanks
In early January, Nick Levintow wrote (above) asking whether there was anything that could be done to stop these senseless deaths in trenches. I think there is a way to stop it.
Since ancient times, it was understood that a person who did not protect others from a fatal hazard under his control could be punished by death for allowing that innocent person to die. It is in the Bible, but I will not go that far. We need to stop seeing these deaths as accidents. They are not accidents, they are negligent homicides.
A very prominent, former US Attorney once told me that people do not like fines, but they HATE GOING TO JAIL. These are matters that OSHA should turn over to local States Attorneys, after OSHA’s investigation and determination of fines.
A few states have prosecuted contractors for deaths in trenches. We need more prosecutions to catch the attention of trench operators.